Your Craft Your Climb — AEC People and Performance
    All Articles

    High-Agency Leadership

    Winning by Not Losing

    What commonly derails AEC firms’ best laid plans regarding talent and leadership

    Zack Tomlin, PE·

    I love when other languages have words that we sorely need in English.

    Like when someone asks you to confirm a negative:

    “You didn’t go to the store did you?”

    Is the answer “Yes“? I indeed did not go to the store (but it sounds like “Yes, I did go to the store“)

    Or is the answer “No“? Your statement is incorrect—but wait “No” implies I did not go to the store.

    (If your head hurts from reading this—mine too from writing it)

    It’s why I like the French word “Si“—used to refute a negative.

    “You didn’t go to the store did you?”

    “Si, I did go to the store.”

    And so I loved it when a friend introduced me to the German word “Kopfkino.” Literally it means “mind cinema” or the movies we play in our head. And often playing out that movie leads to an ending we’d rather avoid.

    It’s a good exercise as a leader. What could go wrong? The “pre-mortem.” The idea being that if we can figure out how we’re likely to lose, and avoid those outcomes long enough, we might just find ourselves winning.

    So how are firms often “losing” when it comes to developing talent and effective leaders?

    For the past few months I’ve been sitting down with architecture, engineering, and construction leaders, asking a simple question: how are you developing your people?

    The same endings kept showing up—predictable ways the whole effort goes sideways. Here are the ones I hear most:

    The urgent drowns the important

    Building development programs gets handed to a principal—the same one having to schmooze clients, write proposals, do technical reviews, and handle a whole host of other pressing matters.

    Or it gets added to HR’s plate—the same team dealing with recruiting, hiring, onboarding, benefits and renewals, legal compliance, and day-to-day issues and conflict resolution.

    In either case the result is the same: good intentions but the important losing to the urgent.

    The mentors are too busy to mentor

    Firms put their faith in senior leaders to bring people along. They pair up mentors and mentees, but the mentoring meeting gets pushed, canceled, or crushed into fifteen rushed minutes. A year goes by and little changes.

    Outside content has no industry fit

    “Industry agnostic” programs show up with no connection to the actual work or time pressures of the AEC industry. People come back saying “it just didn’t feel like us.”

    It aims at the wrong target

    Too much “courage, belief, passion” — the inspirational register — and not enough of the actual tasks of leading: running a hard conversation, delegating a project, developing a direct report. Motivational, but nobody leaves able to do anything differently.

    And the quiet killer: no takeaway

    The one I hear most. People finish a program and can’t name a single concrete thing they now do differently. That’s the tell. If no one can point to one changed behavior, the firm paid for an event, not a change.

    The firms that struggle least aren’t the ones with the cleverest program. They’re the ones who stopped treating development as a bolt-on and started grounding it in a holistic view of the real roles, tasks, and skills their people need — ideally taught by someone who gets their industry, in a format that respects how busy they are, with something concrete to show at the end.

    If you’re seeing how this movie might play out in your firm—and not loving the ending—I’d love to connect and write a better ending to your “Kopfkino.”


    I’m Zack Tomlin, former AEC firm owner and founder of Your Craft Your Climb. I work with AEC firms and their staff to develop their most valuable asset: their people—and the leaders and organization that support them. Learn more about working with Zack.

    Further Reading

    Get In Touch

    Contact Us

    Have a question, want to know more, or just want to say hello? Submit the form below and we'll get back to you.

    Book a Call with Zack
    Your Craft Your Climb — AEC People and Performance

    There's a new option for AEC firms.

    A faster route to effective leadership.

    Built by someone who's made the climb before.