High-Agency Leadership
Missing Information vs. Poor Mental Models
Why the honest answer is so often “it depends”
What’s the capital of Kentucky?
Whether you know the answer or not, you’re comfortable with the question.
It’s clear, precise, and what’s “baked-in” to the question is correct.
Kentucky is a state, like 49 others, and we know all of them have capitals. And whether you know them all, or only a few, you know the only thing that stands between you and a good grasp of the United States—50 States—the capital of each, is just missing information. How you “hold” US geography in your head, your mental model, is correct.
Mental Model: An internal representation of external reality—one we use to interpret information, solve problems, make decisions.
Now, what’s the capital of Cleveland?
In the construction and design world we know there’s a sequence to putting a building together, most commonly (and simplified):
- Foundation
- Structure
- Envelope
- Finishes
- Furniture
- Occupant Complaints
And having the correct mental model of that sequence helps us ask better questions and make better decisions.
If a grading crew is on site and someone shows up and asks: “Where does the wallpaper go?” we’d be some form of amused, confused, or perhaps concerned about their mental stability.
“Over there” might be technically correct, but it misses the point—there’s no good way to answer the question.
It highlights the difference between someone who is simply missing information (an input to a valid mental model of the situation) and someone whose “structure” of the situation needs to be rebuilt.
Not knowing the capital of Kentucky is missing information; looking for the capital of Cleveland or where to hang the wallpaper when a bulldozer is in your way are signs of a “structure” in need of repair.
Determining whether we are simply in need of missing information or in possession of a flawed mental model is key to growth and development. Unfortunately, it is very hard to do.
It’s hard to know what we don’t know, it’s hard to know when our own mental models are underdeveloped, it’s hard to see the important nuance that our more simplified view may be overlooking.
It’s easier to distinguish between the two in those we’re helping to develop. To spot the disconnect when we’re asked a question that just doesn’t “sit” right.
But there’s a phrase in each that can signal an opportunity for improvement.
Suppose someone asked you “How do buildings get built?”
You could give them the sequence discussed prior, but as an AEC professional you know a better response is “It depends.”
Delivery method, construction type, pace of schedule—there is a long list of variables that might be important in forming the correct answer. And the fact that you are aware of those variables and can then assign them weight shows your level of insight and understanding—i.e. the complexity of your mental model.
Unfortunately, helping others structure their mental model is more difficult than answering “over there.”
On the leadership and people side of AEC firms I see incomplete mental models mistaken for lack of information often:
- What motivates employees?
- How do we hire better?
- What’s the best way to give feedback?
- How do I hold someone accountable?
- What makes for a good leader?
The unfortunate answer, the one most difficult to sell, but also the most honest: “It depends.”
For example, there is no one universal motivator for employees. Some have more extrinsic motivation—money, status, etc.—others more intrinsic—accomplishment, challenge, etc.—others altruistic—doing good for others and the world—and many are some combination of the three.
The number of possibilities is too great to remember like typical “missing information” and so we’re in need of a mental model that can help us cycle through possibilities as situations arise.
We increase our capacity to lead and to manage people the same way we increase our capability as architects, engineers, contractors, and similar professionals: not by cataloging information but by improving our mental models.
In design and construction those models might be about sequencing, materials, physics, geometry, labor, cost, or risk. In leadership and management there are models of how teams and organizations function, the economics of AEC firms, and most importantly: people—how we make sense of each one. Because almost always, “it depends.”
So, the next time someone is coming to you for an answer, the next time you’re looking for an answer yourself, ask yourself what lies at the heart of the matter—a lack of information or the need for better “structure” in how one is thinking about the issue.
The latter may be more work, but it’s also what increases the capability of ourselves and of our team. Looking up the capital of Kentucky is the easy part—it’s Frankfort btw.
I’m Zack Tomlin, founder of Your Craft Your Climb. I help firms develop better mental models about people, management, and the business side of the AEC industry in the leaders they depend on.
For more on how leaders think, see Mental Models and First Principles Thinking, and on understanding the people you lead, see Cognitive Empathy — Knowing Your WHO. Ready to put these ideas to work? Work with Zack.
Further Reading

